Comparison infographic by Southside Paint & Wallpaper detailing the differences between oil-based and water-based paint primers.

Choosing Between Oil-Based and Water-Based Primers: What’s Right for You?

Imagine you have perfectly planned your home makeover journey. You have chosen the shades for every wall, wall finishes, and also decided how you are going to start and proceed. However, just like most people, one can completely miss out on the primer.

Primer is the actual onset of the painting process. It is used so that the wall does not remain imperfect for the paint. It also enables the paint to stick to the wall.

The multiple types of primers include oil-based, water-based, stain-blocking, and adhesion-boosting. Primers receive the least amount of attention, and not even half as much glamour as paint and finishes get. That is one of the reasons why people miss out on it. However, it is the most important step in the process. A wrongly chosen primer, or uneven application of it, can cause quite a disruption in your final outcome.

Oil-Based Primer — The Gritty, Unapologetic Veteran

Southside Paint & Wallpaper logo with a colorful paint fan graphic, next to the red Benjamin Moore logo.

Oil-based primers have earned their stripes through decades of loyalty. They’re the type of product that walks into a mess, rolls up its sleeves, and says, “I’ve seen worse.” High-gloss trim that sneers at average primers? Oil-based grips it like a determined climber on a cold cliff face. Stains from water, smoke, or stubborn wood tannins? These primers silence them with the confidence of a seasoned guard on patrol.

Wood especially appreciates oil-based primers. They seal the grain, muzzle knots, and keep natural oils from sneaking through and sabotaging your final coat. If you’re restoring an older home—or working with surfaces that have lived several artistic lives—oil-based formulas are the dependable anchor.

Their downside? The aroma hits you like a rude guest who arrives early and stays too long. They require mineral spirits for cleanup, and their drying time is anything but hasty. But for durability and stain obliteration, oil-based primers remain in a league of their own.

Water-Based Primer — The Nimble, more Eco-Friendly Contender

Can of INSL-X MAX BLOCK water-based stain blocking primer.

Among oil-based primers vs water-based, Water-based primers—often labeled as latex primers—have surged in popularity because they’re gentler, quicker, and more forgiving. Cleanup is practically effortless: a little soap, warm water, and you’re back to your day. They dry with remarkable haste, allowing ambitious weekend warriors to move from priming to painting before the inspiration fades, being the best primer for wood.

These primers have an elastic quality that helps them endure expansion and contraction something every Canadian wall experiences like a seasonal mood swing. For fresh drywall, smooth interior projects, and most previously painted surfaces, water-based primers are more than capable.

Their Achilles’ heel is stubborn stains or resin-heavy woods. While newer formulations are improving, they still don’t quite match the brute force of oil-based stain blockers.

Deciding Between the Two Your choice ultimately depends on what your surface has endured and what you expect it to become. 

Choose oil-based if:

  • You’re dealing with severe stains or stubborn smoke damage.
  • You’re priming bare, knotty, or resinous wood.
  • The surface is glossy, slick, or uncooperative.
  • You want rugged durability, especially on baseboards, trim, and high-touch areas.

Choose water-based if:

  • You want a breathable, low-odour environment.
  • You’re working on a tight timeline and need fast drying.
  • You’re painting new drywall or previously coated surfaces.
  • You want simple cleanup and fewer harsh chemicals.

Some painters swear by a tactical hybrid approach: oil-based primer for problematic areas, topped with water-based paint for flexibility and aesthetic charm. This blend often delivers the longevity of an old-school method with the comfort of modern convenience.

When your friends and/or family visit your newly renovated place, they are not going to ask what primer you used, as that’s the last thing to get noticed. However, the final appearance of your home owes a lot to the primer you used.

Using high-quality primers like Benjamin Moore Aqua Lock will make your living space look pitch-perfect after the painting work. The paint is likely to last, and the finish will show its best. For those who don’t want their paint to start to chip off within 5 years, using primers like INSL-X primer correctly and wisely is crucial.

Also Read: Choose Paint Colours that Make Small Rooms Look Bigger

When it comes down to choosing between oil-based and water-based primers, the real secret is paying attention to what your surface truly needs instead of guessing and hoping for the best at the Exterior Stains Store in Milton. Every wall, every piece of trim, every stretch of tired wood carries a story—some riddled with stains, others simply waiting for a clean slate—and the right primer acts like the quiet architect who rebuilds things from the inside out. Oil-based primers step in when strength and stain-fighting power are non-negotiable, while water-based primers shine when ease, speed, and low odour matter just as much as performance.

FAQs

1. What are the crucial materials for painting the insides of a home?

Apart from the correct equipment like brushes, rollers, safety layers, and a ladder, primer, paint, and finish are crucial.

2. What types of primers are there?

The types of primers are as follows, but aren't limited to, oil-based primers, Water-Based primers, and Shellac-Based primers.

3. What is the most basic purpose of primers while painting the wall?

Primers help the paint to stick to the wall in an enhanced way. The paint’s lasting presence on the wall is due to primers.

4. When is the time to apply primer?

After sanding the wall and before applying the paint is the right stage to apply primer.

5. Where do I find an appropriate primer for my choice of paint and wall?

At Southside, we offer the best quality primers for your walls to look stunning and flawless. We also assist you in choosing the suitable one. We are the most adored paint, finish, and primer Store in Milton.

Back to blog